
The good underdog story behind the great underdog movie.
Mike Stallone wants to be a movie star, but despite his sharp mind, people cannot look beyond his slurred speech. Living rough on the streets, he finally gets a big break when he writes a screenplay called “Rocky”. But studio executives refuse to let him act in the picture… Is it possible for him to rise above other people’s impressions of him?
Director Peter Farrelly (Green Book) give us I Play Rocky, a biopic exploring the creation and production of 1976’s hit movie Rocky. It stars Anthony Ippolito, AnnaSophie Robb, P.J Byrne (Coyote Vs ACME) Toby Kebbell, Tracy Letts, and Stephan James. There’s been a few movies-about-movies made over the last half-decade. Spurred on by the rise of streaming services and the “death” of cinema. But Rocky‘s backstory is quite an inspiring tale, and we finally get an interpretation now.
Does it live up to the drama behind the scenes?
The film follows Mike Stallone, a man living in New York with a dream. A dream to be an actor. But a birth defect causes his speech to slur, and every audition ends the same way. His determination lands him living on the streets or working meager jobs. A lucky encounter and some inspiration later, leads him to write a screenplay for a movie. The studio he approaches love it and want to make it. But they blanche at Mike’s insistence that he must play the lead role. Does his determination continue to fail him?

Of course, Mike Stallone in this story is the alias of one Sylvester Stallone, taken up during this time in his life. His speech being so crippling to his self-esteem that he went by another name. Anthony Ippolito plays the young Stallone here, both with grace and physicality. It is a fantastic performance; sometimes it is hard to tell if the footage is from 1976 or not! Ippolito captures the speech, as well as the awkward confidence that the man had.
That is to say, the man had during the time of Rocky‘s production. Indeed, as is the premise of the movie, Rocky was Stallone’s movie. But it was also a crucible for him as an actor; one massive audition for the life he wanted. The film does good work in pacing the before-Rocky with the production on Rocky. We see how far he strived to attain his goal, then how difficult it was to keep hold of it. There are some grim moments as this untrained individual throws himself, without question, into the fierce production schedule.
The supporting cast are also really solid. A lot of the levity comes from their reactions to the absurd situations that unfold. The movie’s setting of the mid-1970s is well represented here. Hollywood at its most confidently rickshaw. Stallone’s studio contacts, Irwin Winkler and Robert Chartoff (Bryne and Kebbell respectively) are great at stunned silences and looks of bewilderment. Their boss’s offers of vast wealth (basically buying the Rocky script) to Stallone being shot down constantly. To their realization when filming begins… that it is truly chaotic. Then there is Jay Duplass as Rocky‘s director, who brings a manic but strong-arm attitude to proceedings. He has some of the best reactions.

I can only double-down on the film’s integrity. For a biopic everything felt good; there wasn’t a performance that rang flat or didn’t fit. The pacing was good. The setting and period was excellently represented. The only issue I have with it would be some of the emotional heft felt too light.
Admittedly, I knew some of the backstory already, so perhaps it didn’t surprise me like it would someone else. But there are emotional beats here that felt a little bit like a checklist. We are done. Moving on. It also has a lot of ground to cover, and some big moments are hand-waved with a title card: “months later” etc. Which, while unavoidable if you are fitting this story into 120 minutes, felt a little silly. I’d have happily watched an extra twenty minutes of this movie and get more of these performances and backstory given to me.
Which is a nice sentiment for a negative point. I want more!
For a movie about a movie that’s uplifting and rewarding, it is uplifting and rewarding. Rocky was written during one man’s personal journey of self-discovery and… in a lot of ways… is a definition of The American Dream. This biopic does it a great service. We see the hardship, we see the lunacy of the development and the shoe-string budgets involved. The playfulness of it, but also the incredible risk involved. A chance at greatness, grabbed and not let go.
It isn’t a boxing movie; it is about Rocky. It is about you.

Additional Marshmallows: Just don’t listen to the now eighty-year-old Stallone’s opinion on AI these days. Yeesh.
